Hand-kneaded, boiled, and baked fresh every day — then paired with wood-fired pizza straight from the oven. Welcome to your new favorite neighborhood spot.
Fresh Every Day
Baked at dawn
Wood-Fired
Real oven, real fire
Made with Love
From scratch daily
Carlstadt Local
Right on Washington Ave
Our Story
503 Bagels & Pizza started with a simple idea: what if a corner spot could serve both the best bagels in town and genuinely great pizza — without cutting corners on ingredients?
Every morning, our dough is mixed by hand. We boil, bake, and slice bagels with the same attention we give our wood-fired pies. It's not the fastest operation in town, but it's honest food made the right way — and Carlstadt has been hungry for it ever since.
Whether you're grabbing a quick breakfast bagel before work, meeting friends for lunch, or ordering a late-night pie, we treat every visit like it matters. That's the 503 way.
Fresh
Baked every morning
From the Kitchen
Real food, real fire, real neighborhood spirit. Here's a peek inside our kitchen.
Find Us
Right on Washington Avenue — easy to find, hard to leave without ordering seconds.
300 Washington Ave
Carlstadt, NJ 07072
Planning a meeting, party, or office gathering? We offer catering for bagel platters and pizza trays. Call us to discuss your event.
Stop by on Washington Avenue or give us a call — your new favorite bagel and slice are waiting.
